Old Country Buffet Reviews

Old Country Buffet has an overall rating of 4.7 based on 36 reviews. Customer feedback on Old Country Buffet is mixed: Old Country Buffet reviewers highlight positive aspects like variety of food options, affordable prices, family-friendly atmosphere, generous portion sizes, which strongly appeal to families, budget-conscious diners, casual eaters. However, Old Country Buffet is often criticized for its inconsistent food quality, long wait times, limited dessert selection, outdated decor.

4.7/5.0

36 reviews

5 Stars

26

4 Stars

6

3 Stars

2

2 Stars

0

1 Star

0

All Old Country Buffet Reviews (36)
Katherine.terrell
May 30, 2026
"I mainly went for the meat station, it..."
I mainly went for the meat station, it ended up being the best part of the buffet. The roast beef was tender and not dried out at all, and the guy slicing it was super nice when I asked for a thicker piece.
The turkey and ham were also warm, fresh, and better than I expected for a buffet. Just a warning though, if you’re trying not to overdo it, the meat station makes that difficult. I’d definitely give it 5 stars.
FORD
May 29, 2026
"Desserts Totally Made My Night"
I went to Old Country Buffet mainly for dinner, but the dessert section ended up being the sweetest surprise of the whole visit.

They had a really nice variety of pies, cakes, cookies, soft serve, and little puddings. It wasn’t anything overly fancy, but it was exactly the kind of comforting, happy dessert spread you want after a good meal.
I loved being able to grab a few small treats instead of having to choose just one. I left feeling full, satisfied, and happy. Easy 5 stars from me.
Dawn.turner
May 25, 2026
"Restrooms were surprisingly clean"
I wasn’t really expecting much, but the bathrooms were actually clean. No weird smell either, which was a nice surprise
Dustin.bolla
May 20, 2026
"Fresh food, just like I hoped"
Went to Old Country Buffet it pretty much confirmed what I already thought, when they keep the food moving, it can be really solid. The salad bar looked clean, the fruit actually tasted fresh and wasn’t dried out, and the hot food kept getting refilled. The chicken and veggies were warm and didn’t seem like they’d been sitting there forever. It’s a simple place, nothing fancy, but I always pay attention to whether buffet food feels fresh, and this visit definitely backed up my good impression. I’d go back
sergio_Roberts93
May 14, 2026
"Only grabbed breakfast, so I can’t speak to..."
Only grabbed breakfast, so I can’t speak to the rest, but it was good. There were a lot of options, and the pancakes and eggs were the standouts for me
beverly1975
May 14, 2026
"Honestly, the food had no business being that good"
I went to Old Country Buffet last weekend and I swear I was not prepared for how good it was. The fried chicken was hot, crispy, and actually juicy, which basically made me question every dry buffet chicken I’ve ever suffered through. The mashed potatoes and gravy tasted fresh too, and I may have acted like I discovered some hidden treasure.

The desserts were simple, but the bread pudding was so good I almost made it my whole personality for the rest of the day. Nothing super fancy, just solid comfort food with tons of choices, and I left completely stuffed and way too happy about it. I’d definitely go back
DianeSevy_24
April 27, 2026
"Nice and not too loud"
We went to Old Country Buffet last weekend, the noise level was better than I expected.

It was definitely busy, but it wasn’t that kind of loud where you have to keep repeating yourself. I could hear my family just fine, even with kids running around and people walking by and, well, all the usual buffet stuff going on.

It made the whole meal feel more relaxed. I like when a place feels lively, but not—let me start that again—not so loud that it wears you out. This was a comfortable middle ground for me.
Richard_mcmurry80
April 06, 2026
"Felt Clean and Safe"
I noticed the Tables were wiped down every time someone left, which made the place feel really clean and Safe. Definitely appreciated that.
david_Brown02
March 31, 2026
"Food Came Out Hot"
The hot food was actually hot, which somehow made a huge difference. The mashed potatoes, chicken, and gravy all came out at a really good temperature, and the salad bar was nice and cold too. It’s such a simple thing, but it just made the whole meal feel way better. I left feeling really happy with it. Definitely 5 stars.
hello_carole875
March 27, 2026
"Solid salad bar, nothing fancy"
I stopped by for a quick buffet meal and the salad bar was good overall. The lettuce tasted fresh, the toppings were decent, and there were enough dressings to choose from. It wasn’t anything fancy, but it definitely did the job. The only thing I noticed was a little mess around the bar, which felt preventable, but it didn’t ruin the experience.
Caroline-tatum
March 26, 2026
"My first impression was good because we..."
My first impression was good because we went at lunch expecting a long wait, but we were seated really quickly. Even once it started getting busier, the food lines kept moving at a decent pace. It was a relief not having to stand around forever with hungry kids.
adam_Doherty72
March 19, 2026
"They handled my complaint quickly"
Had a small issue during my visit. Not ideal. But they got back to me really fast and made things right. happy with how they handled it.
lewis1994
March 11, 2026
"Food was just okay, seasoning was all over the place"
I ordered from Old Country Buffet the food was average. The fried chicken was decent, I’ll give them that, but some of the sides were so bland it was kind of annoying. Like, how hard is it to add a little salt or seasoning?

The mashed potatoes tasted super plain, and the veggies were soft but didn’t have much going on flavor-wise. It wasn’t terrible or anything, but it definitely wasn’t the kind of meal I’d be thinking about ordering again anytime soon.
JeremyJones
March 10, 2026
"So many options"
There was a lot to choose from. Breakfast items, meats, desserts. A little bit of everything. I never felt like I was stuck with the same few options, which was nice. Just a solid buffet overall
LANE
March 02, 2026
"Manager got back to me really quickly"
I had an issue, and the manager got back to me fast. it was handled without any hassle, and everything got fixed quicker than I expected
HarrisTucker_37
March 02, 2026
"Better Than I Expected for a Quick Family Dinner"
We grabbed this for a quick family dinner, and it was a better deal than I expected. The food was decent, nothing fancy, but everyone found something they liked and the price felt worth it overall. For a simple no-fuss meal, I’d say it did the job well.
LonaArchila
February 25, 2026
"I checked oldcountrybuffet.com before taking the family out..."
I checked oldcountrybuffet.com before taking the family out, and the prices were easy to find. No weird hidden fees or surprise charges when we got there, which was nice. It was basically exactly what I expected, and I really appreciated that.
hello_robert480
February 20, 2026
"The food trays were getting refilled really fast..."
The food trays were getting refilled really fast and I didn’t have to stand around waiting, which was nice because everything stayed fresh and it just made the whole thing feel easy.
cody_Smith79
February 15, 2026
"We took our two kids to Old..."
We took our two kids to Old Country Buffet and it was way easier than I expected. There were lots of food choices, so nobody was whining about not finding something to eat, which is always a win lol. The staff didn’t seem annoyed even when the kids got a little loud, and the tables had enough space so we didn’t feel crammed in. It’s not fancy or anything, but for a relaxed family dinner it worked out really well.
AlexandraMerrick_45
February 05, 2026
"Dining area seemed clean"
The dining area looked clean to me, I think. The tables were mostly wiped down, though maybe I just came at a good time.

View More Reviews

Have a question about Old Country Buffet?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.